Reviews for

Mastering the Knife

Readers of Mastering the Knife have encountered this message when attempting to place a Review of my work on Amazon:

“We apologize but this account has not met the minimum eligibility requirements to write a review. If you would like to learn more about our eligibility requirements, please see our community guidelines.”

This is the reason my readers have sent their evaluation/review of my books to me, the author, asking me to place their evaluation on my website. Amazon is a private company and is within its legal rights to set their rules for customer participation.

However, this statement seems to be an unhelpful bias not only to the author’s work but ultimately also to Amazon. To the author, it excludes honest public opinions of a book that was obtained from Amazon, thus unfairly preventing other Amazon readers to assess the merits of the book. To Amazon it discourages further sales of a product that would benefit their sales.

Mastering the Knife reaches beyond the purely personal to convey something of the people, period, and places that made the author. Working sometimes like a memoirist and sometimes like an anthropologist or ethnographer, he lifts a veil on the rites, rituals, rules (written and unspoken), and language of medicine, especially surgery.

Meguid is a masterful storyteller, and the story that he seems to have lighted on is about the peculiar mixture of temperament, intellect, skill, circumstance, discipline and luck that go into the making of a remarkable life. Some powerful forces are arrayed against him, of course: racism and xenophobia as well as parental cruelty, neglect and abandonment. The author gets a lot of narrative momentum from the sense of pushing against the forces—even the ones inside his own head—agitating for defeat and failure.

Scenes are captured the drama of a particular moment in very few words. Much of the dialogue is crisp. Sometimes it’s laugh-out-loud funny. Whenever the author turns his descriptive powers on a place—whether landscape or structure—the writing turns vivid and evocative. Much of the prose about the practice of medicine or surgery, as seen through the eyes of a student, is precise and memorable. The reader finds herself being educated through Meguid’s eyes.

Jennifer Brice

Associate Professor of English, Author of Unlearning to Fly

We follow him to the prestigious London University Medical School where he is the ultimate outsider, an Egyptian in a lily white, elitist English world. But he prevails, and in the end, Meguid finds belonging, love, affection, and a fulfilling career that takes him to Harvard in historical Boston for a planned surgical residency. Throughout medical school in London Dr. Meguid illuminates a path filled with rejection, longing, sadness, relentless pursuit, and ultimately fulfillment, joy and unbridled success. You owe it to yourself to join him on his life’s adventure.” 

Joan Gerberding

Past National President, American Women in Radio & TV

I want to tell you how much I enjoyed Mastering the Knife even more than Roots & Branches.

Your writing is powerful and elegant. You keep me personally and emotionally connected throughout. You know how to tell such a compelling story, just at the right pace, with just the right amount of narration and back story to keep me going. I had my choice of reading Edith Wharton or you and chose Mastering the Knife.

Jan Pendleton

Fiction Writer, CA

I would like to thank you for writing Mastering the Knife. I have enjoyed it so much as my bedtime reading. I kept staying up too late and had to ration myself. I relived it all with you!

Professor Cartwright

Colchester, UK

Having just finished Michael Meguid’s two books–Roots & Branches and Mastering the Knife–I was totally overtaken with the journey that the author has taken. It is a powerful story portraying the turns and events of life and a truly heart rendering experience. I look forward to Dr. Meguid’s next book. I highly recommend these two fabulous books. –5 stars.

Richard A. Lynn

MD, FACS